who was obsessed with women. He thinks about himself as a passionate lover and wants to take away all the problems from his girlfriends life even if it means killing her best friend. :P) but another reader likely wouldn't have. Azevedo, J., Vieira-Coelho, M., Castelo-Branco, M., Coelho, R., & Figueiredo-Braga, M. Even though he is outright creepy, you cant really spot whats going on in his mind. 10. Joe Goldberg has established specific coping methods when it comes to functioning in high impulsive aggression and higher premeditated aggression (Azevedo, et al. He is incapable of being in love with anyone. It can also be seen that Joes fear of abandonment leads him to possess anyone he becomes infatuated with out of a fear of unreciprocated feelings. Copyright 2020 mentalhealthmatters-cofe.org. Verywell Mind content is rigorously reviewed by a team of qualified and experienced fact checkers. While working with Mr. Mooney as a teen, he adopted Joe. 12 Oct 2020 Co-dependency: Healing the human condition. a woman, he needs to be overprotected. Burger, J. M. (2019). This is really well done, Justin. Pastoral Psychology, 50 (1), 3952. Visit Insider's homepage for more. Even when he is having some really monstrous thoughts in his mind, you cant really have a clue. Joe Goldberg is a character in the novel and television series You who has been diagnosed as a narcissist by many readers and viewers. He hurt his loved ones and others whom he suspected. Please consider adding this before the end of the course. She relied heavily on Joe this season to clean up her murders and craft stories to ensure that the killings never pointed back to her. Joe Goldberg wants you. Date: September 22, 2020, Comparison of Theorists: Joe Goldberg As a result, you may have found yourself wondering how accurate the series' depiction of stalking is. It is possible to modify the four steps of the original cycle of abuse in narcissistic relationships. Joe will do whatever in his means to help them out in "You". One in six American women and one in 17 American men are victims of stalking in their lifetimes, making this an important question, especially since Joe's stalking goes far beyond the man in a trench coat lurking in the bushes we often imagine. She received her bachelor's in broadcasting and mass communication from State University of New York at Oswego, and lives in Buffalo, New York. Lets get to the bottom of it, shall we? the foster system for years, Joe had found a job at Mr. Mooney's bookstore. As part of this process, the individual is first idealized, then devalued, re-examined, and eventually discarded when no longer necessary. "If he was my patient in season 1, sure, he could be diagnosed with antisocial personality disorder, but upon further excavation, his behavior reveals itself as a trauma symptom versus antisocial personality disorder.". Joe Goldberg is one of those rare sociopaths who come across as very charming. In previous seasons, it was easy to see Joe as a psychopath due to his severe obsessions and violence with women, but there is more to Joes mental state than meets the eye. : an American History (Eric Foner), The Methodology of the Social Sciences (Max Weber), PSY 255 Trait Theory Short Answer Worksheet, Introduction to Personality Media Analysis Worksheet, Persuasive Essay-Thesis Statement and Gathering Resources Worksheet. Is Joe Goldberg a Sociopath or a Psychopath in You? - The Cinemaholic Furthermore, only some people with narcissistic personality disorder reach the level of malignant narcissism, the most severe form of the condition. Season 3 of "You" is slated to debut in 2021. He is a great example of how someone can be diagnosed using psychoanalysis. The 33-year-old actor's comment was made in response to Colbert asking him: "Do you have anything to say to the people out there that say they want to date Joe, despite the minor flaw of murdering people?" "It's not a clinical portrayal of a serial killer," Badgley said after defending fans. Rejected stalkers want both revenge for the rejection and reconciliation with the person who rejected them, with their inclination toward both impulses changing on a regular basis. Mind in the Media: What's So Appealing About Oddball Wednesday Addams? We Need To Talk About The Home & Away Twins With A Telepathic Connection Who Werent Actually Related, We Need To Talk About How Love Is The Real Psychopath Of You, 8 True Crime Shows To Stream After American Murder: The Family Next Door, Some Extremely Baffling Info Has Come To Light About Ellys Time On The Bachelor, We Need To Talk About The Home & Away Twins With A Telepathic Connection Who Werent Actually Related. Joe thinks it was he who . INFJs frequently become overwhelmed by other peoples emotions, lose their own identities, and seek out ways to please others. But in the end, he didnt. generating situations develop strategies for dealing with threatening people. While individuals who seem excessively self-absorbed or have an inflated sense of self-importance are often referred to as narcissists, those with narcissistic traits don't necessarily qualify for the diagnosis of narcissistic personality disorder. Let us break down his character and actions to view the psychological perspective of Joe Goldberg. ", Joe's behavior could even seem romantic "to those of us who have been brought up on Disney and rom-coms practically IV-dripped into our consciousness. 2. The reason is the way he carries himself in front of people. Beck was born on December 3rd. have learned that social relationships are a source of anxiety, and their destructive interpersonal "Empathy is really about how we are compelled to understand why things are the way they are. Even though he is outright creepy, you can't really. Even though he is scared internally, he appears normal from outside because subconsciously he is confident and knows how to get away. Yet, the series doesn't acknowledge this reality. There, youll also find thoughts and questions by our community. Top editors give you the stories you want delivered right to your inbox each weekday. "Mental health relies on nuance because it is nuance," Scott said. As a psychologist, what would be your diagnosis of Joe Goldberg - Quora These flashbacks help viewers better understand the root cause of Goldberg's behavior and, according to Scott, these scenes led her to believe Goldberg acts how he does not because he lacks empathy and has antisocial personality disorder, but because his violent and turbulent childhood caused him to develop an attachment disorder. Joe is a narcissist who desperately seeks to fill his emptiness because he craves supply. 2023 Dotdash Media, Inc. All rights reserved. Joe, a rare INFJ, has a serious personality problem. But at least Joe was methodical and careful in his approach to murdering people. We explore Joe Goldberg's personality type, best personality matches, zodiac sign and Enneagram type. INFJ is a combination of the three functions (introverted feeling, moderately developed sense-making, and judging abilities). Joe Goldberg is a textbook example ofYandere. Another season 2 scene, when Goldberg says he won't kill Forty even though he hates him because he means so much to Love, further suggests Goldberg has empathy, to an extent. Joe is very narcissistic and has a grandiose sense of self. Proudly created with Wix.com. Love craves violence and chaos, and that was very clear in Season 3. And if it comes to saving his a$$, he can kill his girlfriend too. -, Narcissistic Personality Disorder: A Treatable Mental Disorder, Unraveling The Mystery Of Extroverts And Introverts: A Guide To Handwriting Analysis, Pronouncing Introvert With Confidence: A Guide To Mastering The Words Correct Pronunciation, Unlocking The History Of The Power Of Positive Thinking, Introverts Unite: Understanding The Dynamics Of Relationships Between Introverts. Joe's abusive childhood experiences and flashbacks played a crucial role whenever he hurt or crossed swords with someone he loved. So let You serve as a guidebook on what not to do in a new relationship. So, to get to the bottom of the You phenomena, we turned to psychologist Perpetua Neo, DClinPsy, for insight on how psychopaths manage to suck us in. 'You's' Penn Badgley Says Fans Can't Be Entirely Blamed for Liking Joe He has often been described as a psychopath, but opinions have differed on what exactly ails our hero. Joe wants to know you, to protect you, to love you. Mullen PE, Path M, Purcell R, Stuart GW. It is essential to know how to help them, as well as protect yourself from the ASPD patients who can potentially hurt you. Love Quinn 'You' Character Analysis: Why She's a - StyleCaster why we do things as we get older. "adult child" (Whitfield, 1991, pg. The fact that both ASPD and psychopathic tendencies can stem from environmental factors also brings us to the rest of our romantic serial killers diagnosis. in his adult-like with the mental, psychological, and emotional abuse as a child or teenager. One thing that could improve this submission is a short summary of the show and characters at the very beginning. Is Joe a Psychopath or a Sociopath? I was honestly truly sad after finishing the series, because I believed Joe could have been a good person. When he becomes involved or thinks he becomes involved with For example, when Beck ex-lover, Benji, whom she did not want in her life anymore. Berlanti, G., & Gamble, S. (Directors). I have watched a bit of the series, so I know what's going on (although I did just get some spoilers! Joe meets many relationship challenges in season three with his partner, Love Joe had a nightmarish childhood. "Joe [Goldberg] would be a good example of misdiagnosis," Scott said. He is attractive according to societys standards of beauty, his monologues in the show consist of great humor which makes him a likeable and relatable character, and the way he treats children shows us that hes rather polite, caring, and respectful (obviously not enough to respect peoples privacy). If you are an Aries, you may find Joe to be overly emotional. You offers an extreme example of what can happen when a psychopath enters your life. Many victims believe they are losing their minds, that they are to blame for the abuse, and that they have no hope of recovering. And no matter what he's doing to win the heart of his latest obsession, including theft and murder, he sees all of his behavior as justified because it is done to help her and their relationship. "[Social media] is a part of our lives today, but use it in a sensible way and don't divulge too much about yourself." Throughout each season, he would stalk the women, and become so involved with their lives that he often ends up getting caught in a situation which compels him to commit unethical and illegal acts in the name of love. Joe devalues his wife, Love, while also gaining his bosss affection in the shows latest season. Verywell Mind uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Then when Joe and Love invited Sherry and Cary over to have sex, Love went beserk when she noticed that Joe was simply fantasising about having sex with another woman. Joe Goldberg - amazon.com "He's positioned as alone in the world, abused and neglected by his mom.". There isnt much planning involved in the Disorganized Killer as there is in an organized killer. However, while this shift in dynamic started to finally mellow out Joe, it turned Love into even more of a psychopath. Do you want to share your story? The Complexity of The Psychopathic Mind., Leiden, Luke. Love Quinn, an unhealthy type of ENFJ personality type, does not belong in this category. Season three of You is unique in that Joe becomes a father, and we get to see more of his childhood and his insecurities in becoming a parent. He is a serial killer, stalker and former bookstore manager who, upon meeting Guinevere Beck at his workplace in New York, starts to develop an extreme, toxic and delusional obsession. some symptoms of being antisocial. They are charismatic and plan everything in advance to ensure that no one notices. As stated in Kwon article, "At first, the Womens Day 2023: Agar Tum Saath Ho, Aarya, Aranyak, Maharani & Other Must-Binge OTT Series To Celebrate Womens Resilience & Strength! Demographics Because . His upbringing is influenced by strong morals, idealistic beliefs, and a desire to lead a better life. Psychoanalysis of "You"'s Joe Goldberg. file]. People with narcissistic personality disorder havean inflated sense of self-importanceand lack of empathy for others, which are typically mechanisms used to mask their low self-esteem, according to the Mayo Clinic. The murders of Joe and Love differ in several ways, as do the types of serial killers. Looking into the perspective that Freud's structure of Id, Ego, and Superego, we can And we try to do that for other people, especially if we are very understanding of other people. Codependence and Interdependence: cross-cultural reappraisal of Joe Goldberg is often described as a psychopath, but this is largely because the term "psychopath" has become a popular tag for the (fictional and real-life) violent killers that grace our screens.The term "sociopath" is also often used interchangeably with "psychopath," but the former, in fact, refers to a person with Anti-Social Personality . Because Joe is a charming character, most people watching the show find themselves rooting for him, even when he is facing the well deserved consequences of his own actions. Hence, Joe seems to have a form of ASPD (sociopathy), as opposed to him being a complete psychopath. I utilize art therapy and bibliotherapy in my mental health work, and I work with individuals struggling with mental illness, as well as their loved ones. Because when we take care of ourselves and our needs first, "that makes us a lot less vulnerable to a love bomber. The abuse of the victim, as well as the use of emotional and psychological abuse, is used by narcissists to control their target. In this article, I will explore existing psychological research on stalker behaviour and parallel these findings with Joe Goldberg's portrayal as one. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth-Thomson Learning. Click here to find out how. Your email address will not be published. From small details, like his obsession Beck's cracked phone in a yellow case, Joe discerns significant personality patterns: "That means you only take care of. but as the show progresses, the more dangerous he becomes, it's clear that he's a sociopath, because now he's moved into antisocial behaviors. All of these traits fit the criteria for someone with psychopathy. Dr. Nicky applies psychoanalysis in one . Moreover, when he stalks Beck's wealthy friend Peach, who believes he's not good enough for Beck in season 1, or the comedian Henderson, who may have predatory intentions toward underage Ellie in season 2, he becomes the resentful stalker who sees himself as defending the downtrodden against these entitled, underserving individuals. Study of stalkers. For example, in season 1 of "You," Goldberg hit a man named Benji, his love interest Beck's boyfriend, over the head with a mallet, locked him in a glass box, and killed Benji a few days later. "[In season 3]," Hatters Friedman says, "he's trying hard to do the right thing and to be a good dad, which implies some ability to attach to others and to have empathy for the child.". Impulsive decision-making, antisocial behavior, and/or little to no guilt and empathy are just a few other traits aside from superficial harm found in psychopaths, which can clearly be seen in Joe. It can be inferred that because Joe was abandoned by his mother, but continued to hold her in high regard, he developed an unhealthy outlook on love and developed toxic codependency. Goldberg committed all of these heinous and unlawful acts without showing remorse and did so for his own benefit in this case, being closer to Beck which suggests he could be diagnosed with antisocial personality disorder, Scott said. Sarah Lynn is an ESTP personality type with both a feminine and masculine side. Many symptoms of ASPD, like difficulty sustaining long-term relationships, having a lack of guilt, not learning from ones mistakes, and repeatedly breaking the law, seem to be clear red flags that Joe suffers from ASPD. Although he has done so much wrong, Goldberg still thinks he is a perfect individual, and lacks guilt to take accountability for his actions or even feel empathy towards the people who he has violated. While Joe does seem to lack empathy for others, it is important to remember that this is only an interpretation and it is possible that he is simply a very troubled individual. In season 2, however, flashbacks to Goldberg's past suggest he could actually be none of those and have an attachment disorder. We can see now that Joe Goldberg suffers from multiple different things, such as Often narcissists fly under the radar because they use their charm and wit to seem normal and unsuspecting. Trauma isnt the primary cause of Joes antisocial and narcissistic tendencies, but it does play a big part in the development of such disorders and behaviors. Joe devalues his ex-girlfriends in order to manipulate the narrative. Pop Culture's Problematic Portrayal of Psychopathy. The Owl, bhsowl.org/5097/arts-entertainment/pop-cultures-problematic-portrayal-of-psychopathy/. And the only reason she was able to do these thingswithout being disturbed by the public was because Love had the funds to open the bakery alone. The popular Netflix series, You, recently released its third season. raised him, and even taught him an education. Although he seems like a nice guy there is something off about him; he has various personality traits where it seems like he is more than one person. Jung sees personality as a whole person and what Anushka Sens Am I Next To Release Digitally This Womens Day, Actress Says Im Fortunate To Be A Part Of Such An Important Film, Farzi: Prime Video Curates A One-Of-A-Kind Show-Themed Perfume That Smells Of Freshly Minted Notes. As we see in season 2 and season 3, his troubled childhood and the fact that he was abandoned by his mother seemingly gave Joe severe codependency issues. definition has now broadened to include anyone who was "wounded" as a child, the so-called We're immune to trickery, we have good taste in partners, and our BS radars are strong, right? It is significant to represent psychopaths, as it would teach us more about antisocial personality disorder, which anyone you know may be suffering from. Everyone has a darkness and a light inside them. The goal of intimacy-seeking stalkers is to enter into a relationship with the person they're stalking, who they believe is meant to be with them. He was also portrayed by Gianni Ciardiello, Aidan Wallace and Jack Fisher as a youth. Lynzee Smith style is a defense mechanism intended to ward off feelings of anxiety". In fact, both Hatters Friedman and Lev point out that even though Joe may seem like he truly loves Beck, Love, or the other women he obsesses over, the show subtly demonstrates that, like a real-life malignant narcissist, he doesn't see these characters as human beings with strengths and weaknesses of their own. He remains private to the general public, but is great at making deep connections with the people he cares about. Hatters Friedman notes there's no single mental health condition associated with stalking. When he would be dealing with Their grandiosity and entitlement are not so visible. Editor's note: This article contains spoilers for the television show "You.". Over time, the you Joe obsesses over changes but his belief in true loveand what he has to do to ensure it happensnever does. He was a sociopath,had co- dependency issues and as slightly hinted by dr. Nick he can have 2 personalities. Stalking: What to Do and How to Stay Safe, What's Not Realistic About Joe's Behavior in You, Behind the Keyboard: Spotting Digital Dating Abuse, The Role of Genetics in Narcissistic Personality Disorder, The Signs of Grandiose Narcissism and How to Deal With It, God Complex: What It Means and Why People Have Them, Understanding Bipolar Disorder and Narcissism. I use my personal experiences with my mental health and health to inform my work. | Abandoned as a child, Child stressful situations due to how he grew up. A lot of this comes down to Love having the luxury of family money, which has always helped to bail her out of sticky situations. Some people who have been diagnosed with antisocial personality Even when something goes awry, "if we already had this preconceived notion that this person is sensitive and emotionally present, it's very easy for us to believe they're a good person.". Your email address will not be published. Joe killed his father to gain love Klestzick, Rebecca. Highest Grossing Hindi Dubbed South Films. Guinevere Beck | YOU Wiki | Fandom When season 1 of "You" aired, fans took to Twitter to discuss Goldberg's mental health, though he's never diagnosed with a particular condition in either season. It is also possible that you will require professional assistance. and respect from his mother, which did not work at the end. "We can see that he's more of a covert narcissist than an overt because covert narcissists seem really shy and sweet. Write something about yourself. Contests2win.com India Pvt. When people are told to believe in their own lies, they engage in a cycle of narcissistic abuse. Because Joe is a charming character, most people watching the show find themselves rooting for him, even when he is facing the well deserved consequences of his own actions. At the same time, more information offered in "You" season 2 suggests Goldberg may not have antisocial personality disorder, but an attachment disorder related to childhood trauma. Instead, she told Joe that she was just pretending to flirt with Theo to get information from his dad. "Although You's depiction of Joe as someone who can feel guilt and empathy toward his victims brings humanity to the character, it's also led some fans to romanticize him. Oops! Naturally, one would be charmed by Joe Goldberg. He is portrayed by Penn Badgley in his first villainous role. Indeed, people with antisocial personality disorder are more inclined to break the law than those with narcissistic personality disorder, psychologist Stanton Samenow wrote on Psychology Today. Speaking of the swingers night, Love wouldnt know how to be lowkey if her life depended on it and it did. As a result, it is clear that Joe Goldberg is likely to suffer from antisocial and narcissistic personality disorder. 2020). So when we have empathy for someone, it hooks us in. 2021 by Medical Wonders Ontario. 38/40. COMPARISON OF THEORISTS: Joe Goldberg Vulnerable narcissists may be more prone to using the cycle of emotional abuse over physical abuse or coercion. Since he is a fictional character, the more we find out about him in subsequent seasons, the more accurate a diagnosis of his mental state can be made. Joe Goldberg Joe Goldberg is a young man who seems to be in his early to mid-20s. Psychopaths tend to be charming at an initial impression; this is why no one ever suspects Joe in either season, and both fans and characters believe that Joe is a likeable person while the people who are against his horrible deeds are viewed as the antagonists. The series chronicles a young bookstore manager with unsavory tendencies (to say the least), and with the release of the show's second season, it has stirred some fascinating questions about why we fall for psychopaths. The Id is described as the "unconscious energy" that strives to satisfy basic sexual and aggressive drives. Joe also loves kids and wants to protect their childhood for the same reason. moments, they both are similar is stating things come from when we are younger and explains What Does It Really Mean To Be An Extrovert. You Characters Ranked By Intelligence - screenrant.com Hence, Joe clearly has issues with codependency, which inform the relationships he forms with women. He is a great example of how someone can be diagnosed using psychoanalysis. Abnormal Psych Case Study.docx - Case Study of Joe Goldberg Delilah Alves. Even though Joe, unsettlingly played by Penn Badgley, is fictional, his patterns of behavior toward the latest object of his desire come across as frighteningly realistic. J Am Acad Psychiatry Law. This article contains major spoilers for the first three seasons of the TV show, You, now streaming on Netflix. Joes development of obsessions with different women often leads to violence due to his inability to create and maintain positive relationships, and he often resorts to violence when he feels as though he is being abandoned. Even though he has been portrayed as an obsessive murderer in previous Use good judgment, be careful with someone who tries to get you alone, and don't share where you live straight out of the gate. National Intimate Partner And Sexual Violence Survey (NISVS): 2015 Data Brief. Kwon, S.-Y. he is a sociopath and is obsessed with Beck, he continually stalks her and gets rid of anyone who will distance her from Joe. The fact that Goldberg comes off as extremely charming from the first time viewers are introduced to him is another reason he could be a narcissist, something that ranges from the full-blown disorder to a personality trait. ", However, You's characterization of Joe Goldberg isn't flawless. Both narcissistic and borderline individuals usually experience chronic instability in their personal Continue Reading 36 Sponsored by PureCare Knee Protector Trust your intuition, watch for the red flags, and, for God's sake, buy some curtains. In the story, Joe is an orphan, and he is ignored by his parents. It is time that we take trauma into account when addressing these disorders and see them for what they are: coping mechanisms. With both Freud and Jung dealing with earlier life and Design: Cierra Miller/STYLECASTER. any situation that presents to them. According to Scott, a season 2 scene when Goldberg looks distraught after he learns his landlord Delilah has been killed proves that Goldberg does indeed have empathy and therefore doesn't have antisocial personality disorder. Joe is a lonely and tech-savvy bookstore guy. Joe seems like a hopeless romantic 8 True Crime Shows To Stream After American Murder: The Family Next Door, 12 Oct 2020 Originally posted by omisteriodasduasirmas. After being in Mind in the Media: How Accurate is The Depiction of Stalking in Netflix's You? A psychoanalytic of Joe Goldberg (You) - Psychology 12 This has helped him cope with dealing with specific You is a show that focuses on Joe Goldberg. As a result, Lev says that the depiction of Joe throughout You, from the voice-overs that detail his thought-process to the fixation on his latest love object, are "very accurate. You have to choose which one to act on. In the third season, we see more of Joes background as an abused child, which led to his development of antisocial personality disorder, narcissism and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). "It's very obvious from the beginning of [You] that [Joe] has narcissistic personality disorder," Lev observes. locked in a glass cage and torture him. It may be just a show, but it can tell us a lot about red flags and how to avoid problematic scenarios. ISBN-13: 9781337559010. For example, when the word psychopath or stalker comes to mind, one would highly likely picture a person with an unlikeable, strange personality who is scruffy, unkept, uneducated, and neither polite nor visually appealing. "What we can learn from psychopaths like Joe," Neo says, "is that we need to have a lot better boundaries. According to Scott, this shift in understanding his diagnosismakes "You" feel like a more realistic portrayal of mental health. In the private sector, as leader of Corporate Intelligence at Motorola, Joe received the Meritorious Award . Some choose specific victims while others choose random victims based on a general sense of injustice and grievance with the world. Famous INFJ Characters - Grace that-romance-built-joe-goldberg-on-you/. I offer a variety of courses and free mental health articles, as well as one on one sessions. (2001). He kills people because he believes that killing them is necessary to protect his loved ones and improve the world around him. Rutledge added that in her expert opinion, Goldberg's actions suggest he has symptoms of certain mental illnesses like antisocial personality disorder and narcissistic personality disorder. As for antisocial behavior, Joe does not have any friends, nor does he make any effort to befriend others, aside from children who he feels obligated to care for.