So, does your favorite ice cream flavor make the list? Vanilla is the classic flavor that everyone loves. A one-note ice cream to be sure, but still, compelling. Were putting Jenis above Graeters here because this ice cream has a silkier mouthfeel and a more pronounced (almost fruity) taste. The mellow vanilla base, however, works as the perfect counterpart, and the toasted oat streusel closes out the ballgame, giving this ice cream a sundae-like feel. Its not as risky as, say, committing to a mixie, and brands big and smallsome who may not even be on your radar just yetare coming out with all kinds of new frozen treats to enjoy. Its silky, its got a solid mix-ins-to-frozen-dessert ratiojust stick a candle on top and youve got a birthday party in pint form. You can catch us eating this tri-color ice cream any day of the week, although it feels especially appropriate for a fifth or sixth birthday party. Related: The 22 Best Vanilla Ice Cream Recipes. We know that sounds wrong, and we acknowledge that it is probably not an entirely accurate take. 3. It was designed to look nothing like how it tastes, serving as a reminder that things arent always what they seem. Things are starting to get really sweet! This ice cream flavor achieves the culinary concept of "flavor layering," which simply means it's both saltyand sweetall at the same time. If youre gonna go lime, go sherbet. Its a great concept, but in execution, it deserves theaxe. Its chocolate cake batter ice cream hits all the right notes (including a rich-yet-not-too-intense cocoa flavor thatll immediately remind you of swiping a little batter when Mom wasnt looking). Even if you dont love peanut butter, you might be into this Jenis flavor. Bonus: The gelato is packaged in BPA-free jars, which are also microwaveable and dishwasher safe. If youre looking for something delicious and affordable, check out these thrifty ice cream flavors. Theres nothing quite like a cold, creamy scoop of ice cream on a hot summer day. Start shopping online now with Instacart to get your favorite products on-demand. Eclipses plant-based pints are routinely sold out, and for good reason: Theyre ridiculously creamy, sans cows milk. We like peanut butter. However, this flavor doesn't tickle everybody's taste buds. Walk into any grocery store, and you can be moderately confident that youll find this in a freezer. Whether you like the fancy flavors like Ben & Jerry's or the classic varieties like plain old vanilla and chocolate, the best ice cream flavors are certainly a matter of taste, and a delicious dilemma as well. Get Ben & Jerrys Cherry Garcia Ice Cream . from brands like Ben & Jerry's and Talenti to gather the best ice creams in supermarkets. The thing about this ice cream is: it tastes like Reeses. Baskin Robbins is known for their wide array of ice cream flavors, ranging from classics like Pralines n' Cream to unique offerings such as Secret Admirer, Cherries Jubilee, and Skillet. Get McConnells Turkish Coffee Ice Cream . & Cookies Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert . , Cinnamon is a highly underrated ice cream ingredient, and oatmeal raisin cookies are also supremely undervalued. Get Hagen-Dazs Dulce De Leche Ice Cream . With that iconic foundation of fat, protein and sugar with a veritable smorgasbord of possible added flavors and textures, you could have a different kind of ice cream every day for a year but thats not always a good thing. Get Ben & Jerrys Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream . Comfort shows, meet comfort food. If youre picking bubble gum, though lets just say you can have mine. These pints contain less than 0.5% alcohol by volume, so while you aren't likely to feel tipsy after eating it, it's probably best reserved for the older crowd. Cheapism may earn a commission if you buy through a link on our site. Birthday Cake / Cake Batter. Can you say, yummy? First introduced by mainstream ice cream company Baskin Robbins, pralines n' cream is a flavor most beloved in the South. The organic and gluten-free Chocolate Mousse is rich chocolate ice cream swirled with fudge, then whipped to make it light enough to qualify as actual mousse. The flavors include: vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, mint chocolate chip, coffee, butter pecan, and cookies and cream. This ice cream feels sort of like a game of chicken as if Ben and Jerry were saying, Oh, you like caramel? 3. (Yes, those are real, and they're both on this list.) Now that thats out of the way, please buy this ice cream. It's wickedly amazing (and vegan). A mint chip milkshake with a couple of Oreos thrown in is a common occurrenceat my house. Prices and availability are subject to change. Cherry Garcia,with its smooth cherry vanilla ice cream, chunks of dark chocolate, and cherry pieces, is still one of the best flavors the duo from Vermont churn. Cookies n cream A fun flavor that combines two classics: cookies and cream! If youre on the hunt for a classic scoop of vanilla to top off a homemade pie recipe, weve picked a store-bought ice cream with serious vanilla flavor and a short ingredient list (no fillers here!). Some brands add a lot more matcha than others, and that can be too much of a good thing. .css-gdccrc{font-family:var(--chakra-fonts-condensed);font-weight:700;font-size:1rem;line-height:0.9;letter-spacing:0.08em;margin-top:var(--chakra-space-0);margin-left:var(--chakra-space-0);margin-right:var(--chakra-space-0);margin-bottom:var(--chakra-space-0);text-transform:uppercase;}@media screen and (min-width: 20rem){.css-gdccrc{line-height:0.9;}}@media screen and (min-width: 23.4375rem){.css-gdccrc{line-height:0.9;}}@media screen and (min-width: 37.5rem){.css-gdccrc{line-height:1;}}Team Infatuation.css-1a7ccww{font-family:var(--chakra-fonts-body);font-weight:400;margin:var(--chakra-space-0);padding:var(--chakra-space-0);font-size:0.6875rem;letter-spacing:0.1em;line-height:1;text-transform:uppercase;}@media screen and (min-width: 37.5rem){.css-1a7ccww{font-size:0.75rem;letter-spacing:0.12em;}}August 17, 2021. But there must be a kernel of truth to it. Keep reading to see if yours is below! Thrifty Drugs had the BEST ice cream ever and it's STILL selling at RITE AID. Texturally, this is softy and creamy, but still hard enough to scoop. Originally aired on KHJ in 1981. Get Breyers Reeses Peanut Butter Cups Ice Cream . We tried the Caramel Brownie just 360 calories in the pint. This is a far cry from any flavor with big chocolate chunks as the chocolate chip flavor is much more reserved in its chippage. Report this Content Exactly like earl grey tea (minus the bitterness). The berries are fully emulsified, resulting in a thick, mauve desert. No need to dig! Every chocolate ice cream Ive had since making that one for the first time is something of a disappointment. Even better, it's topped off with swirls of delicious caramel. It's rich, creamy, and always satisfying. Among them: Mint Cookie, with vanilla ice cream, chocolate cookie swirls, dark chocolate ice cream, and mint ice cream with chocolate cookie pieces; and American Dream, featuring blueberry ice cream, vanilla ice cream with strawberry swirl, and strawberry ice cream with chocolate chips. Traditionallyas Moose Tracks is, in fact, a branded flavor only licensed out to a few different companiesthis flavor is made with vanilla ice cream, peanut butter cups and fudge swirls. In the case of Haagen Dazs' Spirits Collection, that's booze and ice cream. Crunchy cookies stand up to the moisture in ice cream without dissolving like cake, but also without freezing into rocky, tooth-busting clods. And it's an iconic partner to a warm slice of apple pie. The city of Naples should sue for defamation. Promise. Although maybe the slight difference at the top of the lists backs my original point. We could definitely use a little more coffee flavor, but we also like how this reminds us of an iced coffee with a hefty pour of oat milk. The results of this poll predictably skewed toward classic, better-known flavors and brands but, at the same time, theres a reason why certain ice creams are successful and well-loved. Marionberry Pie ice creamfeatures them in jelly swirls paired with chunks of pie crust in a vanilla base. We tried Decidedly Chocolatelover's ice cream, which is melt-in-your-mouth creamy perfection. Heather Martin is a registered dietitian and candy corn science correspondent. Freshly made paletas every day that can be customized with chocolate dipping add toppings and fruits. Hands down, mint chocolate chip is the best ice cream flavor around. The fact is, theres a lot of great ice cream out there. All you need now is a spoon. Or worse, they use the mortal sin of fake cherry flavor. This list obviously isnt all-encompassing, but it also wasnt meant to be. 5 . New York Super Fudge Chunk is the ice cream equivalent of that one imaginary friend (Bing Bong?) And the audience goes wild! Which ice cream flavor you prefer may mostly be subjective, but that's not stopping most of us from agreeing that when it comes to a scoop or two, chocolate and vanilla reign supreme. If you're wondering what, in fact, the difference is, french vanilla is marked by a French style of ice cream that utilizes egg yolks in the base. But we hardly ever think of it now. Thrifty Ice Cream (40 flavors) available in cones, waffle cones, cups and take home containers in pint and quart sizes. Breyers Delights. Like, when you shove a tube of cookie into a pint of ice cream, its not really ice cream anymore, right? It is usually richer and has a stronger flavor than American ice cream. Timeless. (McConnells also gets a high grade in the texture department. Chocolate - This is a classic flavor that never goes out of style. Albertsons makes it easy and convenient to pick up the best-loved ice cream, novelties, and gelato varieties from brands like such as Haagen-Dazs, Ben & Jerry's, Breyers, and Blue Bunny. Get Van Leeuwen Chocolate Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert . Banana Nut Birthday Cake Black Cherry Blueberry Cheesecake Bubble Gum Butter Pecan Cappachino Crunch Chocolate Chocolate Chip Chocolate Malted Krunch Made with only five ingredients, Haagen-Dazs has mastered the decadent coffee flavor and smooth texture of this elegant ice . Weve all had chocolate-covered pops that taste more like a waxy, brown-colored coating than anything else. The warmth of real cinnamon is a nice foil for cold cream, as long as its real ground cinnamon. Tillamook and marionberry go together like Stan Smiths and Phoebe Philo. Half of you think vanilla is too high on this list, and the other half think its too low. Did we change? Ben & Jerry's. Breyer's. Edy's. Friendly's. Hagen-Dazs. The Best Ice Cream Scoop for a Perfect Ice Cream Sandwich Every Time | Effortlessly Scoops All Types of Ice Cream, Gelato, Sorbet, & More with Just One Hand . A base of vanilla ice cream is filled with velvety almond ice cream and a brown butter sauce and surrounded by a layer of decadent milk chocolate you can crack with your spoon. Enjoy the mystery. Worst: Ben & Jerry's Pistachio Pistachio ice cream 280 calories, 50% saturated fat, 19 grams of sugar. Regardless, the mocha/cookie combo is elite. Find it at most major grocery stores nationwide.