Symptoms After Being Strangled,
Riddell Speedflex Helmets,
Industrial Attachment Vacancies In Zimbabwe 2022,
Ancient African Social Structure,
Gemma Longworth Pictures,
Articles M
This concerns me because racial representation becomes more problematic when associated with the writers than it does with the characters. Both women say they have faced racism from relatives. Why do Cam and Mitch decide to leave the restaurant at the end? perpetuates as they go through the series. There have also been many emotional scenes that have never failed in pulling at the audience's heartstrings. It may be offensive, but we have context for his actions and can find the humor in his terrible solution to the situation. It was most definitely a combination of both of those reasons. What works though is the small moments. He and their son then avoid them like the plague and treat them like a lepers , Season 8, Episode 2 A Stereotypical Day, When a black family moves in next door, Jay goes out of his way to seem as un-racist as possible, all the while exposing his small thinking. Another entry with Cam & Mitchel. For decades, audiences have fallen in love with sitcoms that put family dynamics on display. Running is the activity or action of moving quickly forward on foot. Being Colombian or Vietnamese are ethnicities. This gives Modern Family an excuse to indulge in a little chaos, with Cam coming up with another way to say he broke his arm while keeping Lilys fear at bay. has continued to be one of the most popular. In the episode, Claire and Haley are at home sick while Phil tries to find an annoying chirping smoke detector. Claire is the typical bossy, controlling, domineering woman who, after painting the town crimson with alphas, has settled down with a beta guy. For sure. By Lynn Gibbs. Forever. That said, it does matter where the truth of the joke is constructed: it doesnt make it racist, nor does it make the producers racist, but it does locate the joke solely on the producers which becomes more problematic when you enter into Savezilla territory. There are a lot of television comedies explicitly dealing with questions of race right now, with 30 Rock in particular proving fairly fearless about creating debates regarding race within the fictional TGS workplace. The writers of Modern Family have never been afraid of making some slightly reductive characterizations. The best bit is when they both agree that they pushed each other to be better, and Earl proposes being added to the show. For once, Manny is actually an asset to the subplot, telling Jay that he shouldnt feed the trolls, and then acting as his guide when Jay decides to go to the guys house and confront him after Alexs computer geek friends track him down. The important thing is that it is his impression, and his panic for better or for worse, the character consciously perpetuates racial stereotypes through his own actions. Glorias hometown is also the butt of jokes on the show on a consistent basis. Did Prince Andrew fly on Jeffrey Epsteins plane Lolita Express? Boyle Heights news, crime, real estate, restaurant. [8] The episode also received a 1.4 rating in the 18-49 demographic in DVR adding up to a 6.2 rating in the demographic a 29% rise from the original rating. However, what bothers me about the parrot scene is that any sort of racial commentary is perpetuated solely in the editing room and by the behind-the-scenes figures in the series. While nothing has been fundamentally changed in terms of questions of race, the show is going to racial humor more often and in a few instances from a different perspective. Racial & sexuality stereotypes arent the only ones that Modern Family perpetuates as they go through the series. Admittedly, Im more critical of Modern Family than many, perhaps because people often associate the series with realism and subversion that the show doesnt actually seem to be interested in. Ill say this: its been awhile since Ive even found a Jay/Manny storyline watchable, so this is nice. You could perhaps make the argument that they were temping in voices, but then why put on the accents like they were? kingston frontenacs best players; how much power does a 4kw solar system produce; emerson college speech pathology acceptance rate. In . There are White, Black and even Asian Colombians. No copyright infringement intended.Visit: https://abc.com/shows/modern-family All of this is to say that the shows representations of race are sort of trapped in this dichotomy between how Modern Family actually operates and how it is perceived. But theres a big problem contained within the premise. Me and Julie in bed all day. Where past subplots have felt like cookie-cutter sitcom ideas that could be used with any couple on the show, this subplot works best with Cam and Mitchell. Gloria Pritchett, played by the gorgeous Sofia Vergara, is easily the most stereotyped character on the show. Comedy Drama Romance Gloria helps Phil figure out why Claire is mad at him, Mitchell forgets to send out invitations to Cameron's fundraiser, and Alex tries to prove that Haley is lying when she says she has a job as a waitress. Gloria (Sofa Vergara) and Manny (Rico Rodriguez) go to pick up Jay (Ed O'Neill) from his workplace to take him to a restaurant for lunch. It was an episode that, somehow, felt even more modern than usual. I would argue that ethnicity has been sufficiently racialized for Glorias accent to have become part of that question. Throughout the entire series, Cam & Mitchel perpetuate an old LBGTQ+ stereotype by playing into the rivalry between gay men and lesbians. That was honestly the most Ive ever enjoyed Lily in a subplot. The joke only makes sense when the editors cut to various moments where Gloria has screeched Jays name in the past, which locates the intention of the joke solely to the process of writing the joke and then cutting the series together. When Jay gets there, its revealed that Earl, his arch nemesis from the closet world, is the troll. It brings out the strengths of Eric Stonestreet and Jesse Tyler Ferguson, and even Aubrey Anderson-Emmons Lily is a delight, knocking out punchlines and keeping pace with her on-screen dads. This article was originally on a blog post platform and may be missing photos, graphics or links. Im just showing them how to teach a kid!. That the joke was constructed in editing doesnt change the simple truth of the joke: Glorias voice is so shrill that the neighbor mistook her for a parrot. Race generally has to do with a physical attribute. university of missouri hospital salaries 2021; port orange arrests today. Mitch and Cam are a married. Thats fine, other than the fact that Phils type is black women.. Phils insecurities are so manifestly obvious that even Luke, his space cadet (in both the literal and the figurative senses) of a son, notices them. Modern Family premiered on ABC Family in September of 2009 and received instant acclaim for its diverse representation of what a family can look like--interweaving the lives of the stereotypical straight, white family, Phil and Claire Dunphy and their three children, with Jay and Gloria Pritchett's age-differing, interracial marriage and their resulting biracial son as well The problem, however, is in the way they are portrayed. It is Filled with Clichs and Racist Stereotypes, What to Do If You Are Haunted by Your Ex? Gender stereotypes are also not safe as they find ways to bring women & men down. The episode was written by Dan O'Shannon and directed by season two's main director, Michael Spiller . My point is not that they cant make the joke, but that the joke is different than jokes we have seen in the past. COPYRIGHT 2020 THE TRENDING BUZZ. It is, after all, a mockumentary structure which has been deemed imaginary: because the writers dont believe this family would allow them cameras into their homes, it becomes an artificial construct which allows the writers to tell stories in a certain way. When a woman walks in with a black baby, they show concern, but Cam calms Mitchel by telling him theyre a gay couple with an Asian baby, assuring Mitchel this makes them better. Making matters worse is the fact that Phil is failing at his own work, too: he cant sell houses anymore. Im just in bed with my momStop freaking out, it is not coming true. --Haley, on the phone with Dylan, whos had some inappropriate dreams about his girlfriends mother, Its bumped out where the boobs go. --Luke, re: Phils allegedly uni-sex apron, Oh, sorry. It depiction of issues of race and homosexuality seems contrived and banal at times. In Unplugged, Jay chastises Gloria for stealing the neighbors dog and says it might be legal in Colombia, but not in the U.S. The idea and conception of this blog came to me as a part of my quest to find the latest updates going around the web. You could argue that the shows lack of attention to their homosexuality makes it progressive, in that no one bats an eyelash of their presence within more traditional sitcom narratives, but thats more a sign of the times than some sort of revolution within the shows storytelling. The series appeal for many is that it gives the appearance of edge with the comfort of the family sitcom: Glee didnt lose to Modern Family at the Emmys because its uneven, but rather because Modern Family is more familiar, and thus easier to swallow, for the Emmys voting body. To top it all, Mitchell and Cameron are both called ladies on more than one occasion by Claire and even Lily! That kind of knee-jerk readiness to be offended is precisely what makes the jokes about Cam/Mitchell being out-minoritied at the daycare center so hilarious. Call them out in the comments below! After Dylan hangs up, Claire tries to convince Haley to break up with Dylan and start going out with David a much brighter kid that Claire prefers (albeit without mentioning either name), using one of the useless male characters on All My Children as an example. Then, they proceed to tell their Asian doctor all the ways theyre going to raise Lily in her heritage. From moments such as Alex's breakdown to the happier occasions, here are the 10 scenes that will not fail in . Do you think it is important for people to maintain a close relationship with the culture of the country in which they or their biological parents were born, even if they have lived their whole life in another country? That is totally racist! Growing up as . From the bumbling idiocy of Homer Simpson and Peter Griffin to the goofy & immature behavior of Tim Taylor that always induced a disappointed wifely scowl, dads are routinely portrayed as being big, dumb animals. He then remembers a myth that women living together will sync their cycles and concludes that all three are menstruating. Phil is the cool dad who was a male cheerleader and loves to be bossed around by his wife. This became explicitly clear in last weeks episode, Chirp, where Camerons efforts to turn Lily into a star are turned upside down by a childrens furniture commercial turning out to be filled with Asian stereotypes (and the conflation of race, with Vietnamese Lily cast despite the commercials clear focus on relating to Japanese culture). This subplot is so misguided, tone deaf, and downright cringeworthy that it completely diminishes everything thats otherwise good in this episode. The new family sitcom Black-ish, created by Kenya Barris centers on portraying the lives of an upper middle class black family and their struggle to maintain their black authenticity.Reminiscent of The Cosby Show, Black-ish is both praised and criticized for its portrayal of African-American families and its perceived unrealistic portrayal. The episode was written by Dan O'Shannon, marking his third writing credit for the series. To sum up: Claire is hiding that shes enjoying the very physical attention shes getting from a yoga instructor, while Phil is lying about his latest client to Claire because he knows shell see the client is exactly his type. Pop culture obsessives writing for the pop culture obsessed. Cameron initially denies the charge, but then the director brings in the SaveZilla (Godzilla) monster. Paris is the thirteenth episode from Season 11 of Modern Family. Its black women, and oh boy does Modern Family not handle it well. The series follows a dysfunctional family shot in a documentary style. Another weighty theme tonight was Phils emasculation. All those passionate makeout scenes between Gloria and Jay? This famous scene from 1978's frat boy comedy "Animal House" takes place in a college cafeteria. I certainly wouldnt argue that theyre flaunting the sexuality of Cam and Mitchells relationship, but that seems more like the nature and tone of the show, rather than some unconscious discomfort with homosexuality. The company mainly sells abroad and the market is concentrated in Europe and Africa. But nobody saw it. Copyright 2020 The Treanding Buzz. The country has gone through so much war and terror, that humor and laughter are always welcomed. It was interesting to see the dynamics between these family members and it gave the show runners so many opportunities to infuse a healthy dose of humor into what should otherwise have been a bland portrayal of suburban lifestyle. "[5], In its original American broadcast, "Chirp" was viewed by an estimated 12.21 million households and received a Nielsen rating of 7.3 rating/12% share meaning that 7.3% of American households watched the episode and that 12% of all televisions in use at the time were watching it. Actually funny how it is the exact opposite in the US. Ethnicity having to do with a place of origin. Shweta Mehta was spotted roaming the streets of Australia in a pink outfit, Nikkita Ghag Made A Big Disclosure About The Casting Couch. The show has had plenty of genuinely funny and heartwarming moments. This scene is from the nineteenth episode of Season 4: The Future Dunphys and originally aired on April 3, 2013. ago Mark is a published novelist and freelance writer specializing in men's style and fashion, self-improvement, and movie news & reviews. All the drama surrounding the duo. A still image from a video posted to social media shows a woman who directed racist remarks at a group of men at a Lethbridge, Alta., restaurant. As anyone who's watched so much as five minutes of the show can tell you, 'Modern Family' is no accident. The shows storylines revolve around minor domestic quibbles, like barking dogs and sullen teens. In The Kiss, when Gloria cooks a traditional Colombian dish made of a pigs small intestines for dinner, Jay retorts why cant we eat regular food like normal people?. Your email address will not be published. In regards to race/ethnicity, yeah I should probably avoid conflating the terms in the same way that television tends to conflate the terms. About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket Press Copyright . is it okay to take melatonin after covid vaccine. Yikes! By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. The two initially bond, but soon Dylan (Reid Ewing) calls Haley, making Claire angry. Lily is cast in a commercial. This may be the least sexualized sitcom on the air right now. 3. Those are ethnicities. I thought this was pretty clear, but perhaps it wasnt. I have to agree with Tausif Khan. From Family Matters and Growing Pains to Malcolm in the Middle and The Simpsons, these shows feature relatable episodes endearing them to audiences, growing their ratings, and cementing them as timeless TV classics. Not all Columbians had big boobs. to which she responds with the information that she is from Denver. New Trend in Dating, The 5 Best Cloud Storage Services for Startups in 2019, The Best Kept Secret Small Business Ideas That Can Make Serious Money, Top Secrets of Maximizing Your Websites Value before Selling It, How To Make Yourself Smarter With Delicious Food, Introducing The Eighth P In Marketing: Why Partnerships Are Now A Vital Piece Of The Puzzle, Cool Summer Foods and What to Do with Them, Muskaan Bamne debuts In Music Video With Amit Mishras Song. Something seems to have changed this season, however: I dont know if the show has bought into its own hype, overemphasizing Glorias accent or wanting to take on broader storylines like this commercial, but it is creating an atmosphere where the show, and not its characters or characters within its world, are being associated with authorship of problematically racial storylines without the unpacking or context necessary to fully comprehend their meaning. 7th episode of the 2nd season of Modern Family, "Monday, October 18, 2010 ABC Television Network PRESS RELEASE - ENTERTAINMENT MODERN FAMILY: Chirp (11/3)", "Modern Family" Chirp (TV episode 2010) - IMDb, "Dan O'Shannon - Filmography by TV series", "Michael Spiller - Filmography by TV series", "Wednesday Finals: Criminal Minds, Law & Order: SVU Adjusted Up", "TV Ratings Wednesday: Up, Up and Up for CBS, Down for Modern Family, Cougar Town, Undercovers, Law & Order: SVU and Law & Order: LA", "Live+7 DVR Ratings: Grey's Anatomy, Parenthood Top Week's Rankings", "TV Ratings Broadcast Top 25: NFL, Modern Family, Dancing With the Stars, Criminal Minds Top Week 7 Viewing", "Modern Family: Episode Recap: "Chirp" Season 2, Episode 7", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Chirp_(Modern_Family)&oldid=1104219815, Articles with dead external links from June 2019, Articles with permanently dead external links, Short description is different from Wikidata, Television episode articles with short description for single episodes, Television episode articles with short description and disambiguated page names, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 13 August 2022, at 14:50. Are there more problematic episodes of Modern Family that you think we missed? Its about gay people, mixed races and different ages getting together and being a family. Unfortunately, Haley thinks Claire is talking about herself and Phil (Ty Burrell). Bluto (John Belushi) first antagonizes the Deltas with his messy impression of a zit before running around the cafeteria eluding them. The racist, homophonic comments are supposed to show realism in families. Its called the black market. --Luke, clutching his Casio keyboard, Its not MGM, its a warehouse behind a mattress store. --Mitchell, Is that your college cheer-leading baton? --Luke, talking to Phil, Complete coverage of Modern Family on Show Tracker, Modern Family recap: Celebrating Halloween with a box of baby Jesus, Modern Family recap: Our long Amish nightmare is over, Modern Family recap: You owe me a murder, Modern Family recap: I feel the Earth move under my feet. Director Dean Parisot Writers Steven Levitan Christopher Lloyd Abraham Higginbotham Stars Ed O'Neill Sofa Vergara The characters include Phil and Claire, who are polar opposites, and their three kids. Maybe Im reading into it all a little too much, but the episode seemed like a semi-sincere reflection on masculinity. [1][4], The episode is the first of the season to feature Dylan (Reid Ewing), Haley's boyfriend. The reveal is beyond tone deaf, and seriously inexplicable as a storytelling device because it isnt funny, nor does it really do anything for Phil as a character. Modern Family is one of the most watched, highest-rated shows on TV today. He plays the piano with chopsticks He plays the piano with chopsticks Maybe its just that good comedy is always about that slight discomfort. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Being Colombian or Vietnamese has nothing to do with race. . It aired on February 12, 2020. Updated Nov 18, 2021. He is from the South, grew up on a farm, and played football as a kid. All the times weve voyeuristically watched Phil and Claire getting busy? Why do you think that is? It endeavored to challenge many of the stereotypical and straightforward dynamics by adding in alternative lifestyles and storylines. While the thin construct of The Office is largely absent and still somewhat unbelievable, at least there exists some sort of logic which would explain the existence of talking heads. The problem, however, is that it is not as modern or as political as it is portrayed to be. I actually love the story-lines they give Gloria, because I actually have gone through these myself and its kind of nice to see it on screen and realize that its not just me that has dealt with those situations! 4. hallofames 3 yr. ago. He was walking on eggshells around her especially after she overhears him complaining about pretentious Ivy League friends at a party. He then remembers a myth that women living together will sync their cycles and concludes that all three are menstruating. However, I do not think that the two are very clearly delineated on Modern Family; because the only questions of ethnicity we see all deal explicitly with questions of race (there are no considerations of white ethnicity, no Canadians, Minnie Driver dropped the accent, etc.) 3rd royal tank regiment records It creates the sense that racism is being constructed as opposed to occurring naturally, that it becomes part of tired sitcom scenarios as opposed to something that would naturally take place in Los Angeles, which is something I do not remember from last season. Mitchell clearly noticed him too, and the two just walk away in awe at the hunk of man-meat they just witnessed. Family Guy Brians date wont say her age. modern family racist restaurant sceneuindy football roster. Posted on June 7, 2022 by Now, arguably, the scene is not explicitly racial: it speaks more to the shrillness of Glorias voice than necessary her accent. Apparently not everyone got the joke. In the meantime, Cameron (Eric Stonestreet) takes Lily to act in a commercial for a children's furniture store, against Mitchell's (Jesse Tyler Ferguson) decision. The Dunphy patriarchs has always felt insecure about his lack of handiness, especially in contrast to his father-in-law. Jake Paul vs. Tommy Fury: Who made the most money from their fight? Before we get to that huge problem though, it must be said that a lot of this weeks Modern Family works because its a hell of a lot funnier than just about any other recent episode. Gloria is a fiery Latina, Cameron is a melodramatic gay man, Jay is a an older white guy who likes to golf. Mitchell arrives at the studio and confronts Cameron, pointing out that the commercial is racist because it exploits Lily's Asianness and not her acting ability. In a video that went viral last week, Michael Lofthouse . Im so happy Im not the only one to take issue with the weird (and what I perceive to be lazy) pseudo-documentary format, and to feel that for all the shows attempts to be progressive its actually taking steps backward every week. In The Incident, Haleys boyfriend Dylan says that the Pritchett/Dunphy family is accepting of hot foreigners and gay dudes. He and their son then avoid them like the plague and treat them like a lepers great lesson for the son. You can contact me (Myles) with opinions, suggestions, or inquiries; I can be reached at cultural.learnings @ gmail.com. Gloria is an immigrant from Colombia and married to Mitchs father, Jay. Manny, touched by Jay calling him his kid, tells him the real location of the date. Without a clear sense of attribution, my focus turned to the ways in which the writers exaggerated the racism of the commercial for comic effect; yes, Cameron eventually unleashes a diatribe against the director, and the undercutting of that speech with the picking up of the wrong baby is legitimately funny, but that the commercial would exist at all struck me as perhaps the most unrealistic thing the show has ever done (especially in comparison to previous concerns regarding race or sexuality, which have seemed more natural). Your email address will not be published. The cast of "Modern Family," Sarah Hyland, left, Ed O'Neill, Nolan Gould, Ariel Winter, Sofia Vergara, Rico Rodriguez, Julie Bowen, Jesse Tyler Ferguson, Ty Burell and Eric Stonestreet, with. For the last decade, Modern Family has continued to be one of the most popular. Is The Family International one of the creepiest modern cults? Some users on social media have claimed the film is "racist," criticizing it for highlighting racism in the 1970s without challenging it. DiCaprio paid $7.1 million, more than the asking price. He fails miserably. sam neill laura tingle split For starters, the title itself! usta tennis court construction specifications / why is rebecca lowe hosting olympics / modern family racist restaurant scene. Ron, the handsome guy from the gym, has to drop it by the house. [15], The A.V. Over the last 11 seasons, the Pritchett-Dunphy-Tucker clan has traveled the globe, making hilarious memories wherever they went - from Hawaii, Australia, Wyoming and Disneyland to Las Vegas, Lake Tahoe and New York. In fact, despite its use of the mockumentary structure which is generally associated with realism, I generally consider Modern Familys plots to be decidedly unrealistic in their organization. Cameron, on the other hand, has an interesting background. They go so far as to tell her about a Vietnamese restaurant and ask the doctor if they are saying it correctly . Modern Family: 15 Of The Saddest Scenes, According To Reddit. Like were Peruvians!. In this clip, we can see Mitch, Cam, and their daughter Lily having dinner with Gloria at a Vietnamese restaurant. Pingback: How I became white perceiving subject: Reading Modern Family through raciolinguistic ideologies . Jay, in particular, takes great pleasure in ridiculing Colombia, its culture, and its customs. . Fans of the movie will notice that the production deviates from an almost entirely white cast to include a more diverse group of performers, including Maya Rudolph as Ralphie's mother, David Alan. For those of you who didnt see the episode, Gloria is exasperated at the way Jay stereotypes Colombia. I stumbled upon it about a year ago, watched the tomfoolery and quite stereotypical antics of the gay couple, noticed there were no blacks and turned it and have not watched it since. The man who was seen on-camera barraging an Asian American family with a racist rant has resigned as CEO of the cloud computing firm Solid8. He is not into sports and not good with tools, but is into figure skating and musical theatre. Later, he has a change of heart and wants to treat him nicely. She goes onto say that the boob jokes are also just for her. rush street bars 1980. lutheran liturgical calendar 2022; drug bust salisbury, md 2020; north berwick witch trials primary sources; hallmark very merry christmas giveaway winners; Hello, Modern Family (2009 2020) is a U.S. TV series that follows the lives of three connected families. At this point, we find out that the cousin is indeed a lowlife who has stolen Jays cigars, for which Gloria admonishes him and kicks him out of the house. And yet, something seems different in the second season. . ABC's Modern Family has always been concerned with questions of race: that Gloria and Manny are Colombian, and that Lily is Vietnamese, were prominent factors in the series' pilot, so questions of race (and racism) have been evident throughout the series. We make safe shipping arrangements for your convenience from Baton Rouge, Louisiana I also agree that Modern Family is something of a broad 90s style comedy pushed into an edgy context for added flavor. I come from a very multicultural family, my dad is Egyptian/Greek, my mum is Indian and my cousins are a varying mix of half Asians and Caucasians. Phils perceived inferiority has been an ongoing joke all along on Modern Family, but tonight, his disappointments were more acute. ! during his online show. Start your day off right, with a Dayspring Coffee But on an episode two weeks ago, Gloria made an off-color joke about Peru that has ruffled some feathers. A native of Bethlehem, Pa., she graduated from Georgetown University and holds a masters degree from New York University. It all adds up to make you realize that this isnt an actual commercial set: its a giant sitcom setpiece purposefully constructed to make these jokes and nothing more. Tips to Select the Perfect Yard Sign Size for Your Event, Best Gadgets to Gift your Dad this Fathers Day 2022, Modern Family Is Not So Modern! Youre only interested in seeing these children as interchangeable stereotypes, not human beings, he says, promptly mistaking his own daughter for a different Asian baby. Modern Family is BORING. Club writer Donna Bowman said "even though these three molehill versions took a while to get cranked up, they provide satisfying and even elegant expressions of what the art of Modern Family is all about". You would think he would be manly enough to compensate for Mitchells over-the-top gayness. And I think the distinction is more important than just a matter of being sloppy. . Cameron takes Lily away, but not before choosing the wrong Asian child first. Pingback: Critics accuse Modern Family of racism Gaming and Film Today. Unfortunately, the following episodes and character arcs perpetuated the very stereotypes they hoped to subvert. 2) Sofia Vergara was asked if she thought there were racial stereotypes like in the episodes you specified. It originally aired on the American Broadcasting Company (ABC) in the United States on November 3, 2010. With Claire sick, Phil takes care of her jobs while trying to find an annoying smoke detector that keeps beeping. Ariel Winter does not appear in the episode.[2]. Visit our. Even Cam, who scolds the commercial director for thinking that Lily is Japanese, is exposed as a minor hypocrite. modern family racist restaurant scene. Racism is a real problem where it exists, but manufacturing it via subtleties of interpretation is one of the most insidious habits university humanities departments have inculcated in their graduates.